Underinsured Motorist (UIM) Claims in California: Exhaustion, Offset and Consent Rules
Short answer: An underinsured motorist (UIM) claim is a claim on your own auto policy when the at-fault driver had insurance, but with bodily injury limits lower than your own uninsured motorist limits. It generally starts only after that driver’s limits are paid out, and it pays at most your UIM limit minus what was paid, under Insurance Code section 11580.2(p).
This page covers how UIM works step by step. For uninsured drivers, see our uninsured motorist claims guide listed further down.
Attorney Advertising. This guide explains California UIM rules and primary sources, not a promise of any outcome. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This page is general information, not legal advice.
When is a driver “underinsured” in California?
Section 11580.2(p) applies only when an injury is caused by an underinsured motor vehicle, and it controls if it conflicts with the earlier subdivisions of the section. Two definitions do the work:
- Insured motor vehicle, (p)(1): a vehicle covered by a liability policy, self-insured, or backed by a cash deposit or bond posted under a financial responsibility law.
- Underinsured motor vehicle, (p)(2): an insured vehicle “insured for an amount that is less than the uninsured motorist limits carried on the motor vehicle of the injured person.”
So the test compares two numbers: the at-fault driver’s bodily injury limit and the uninsured motorist limit on your vehicle. If the other driver’s limit is equal to or higher than yours, the vehicle is generally not underinsured under (p)(2), even if your damages are larger than what that driver’s policy pays.
Under subdivision (n), uninsured and underinsured coverage are offered as a single coverage, and UIM limits are offered equal to your uninsured motorist limits, with higher UIM limits allowed. Check your declarations page for the limit that applies to you.
How does a UIM claim work step by step?
Some situations follow a different path, but a UIM claim generally involves these steps. Written consent comes before any settlement with, or judgment against, the at-fault driver:
| Step | What the statute says | Subdivision | What to keep |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Confirm the threshold | The other vehicle’s liability limit is less than your uninsured motorist limit | (p)(2) | Both declarations pages or limit letters |
| 2. Give notice of any suit | A copy of the complaint goes to your UIM insurer “forthwith” | (p)(6) | Proof of personal service or certified mail |
| 3. Get written consent before settling | No settlement or judgment against a liable person without your insurer’s written consent | (c)(3) | The consent letter, dated |
| 4. Exhaust the at-fault policy | All liability policies of the insured vehicles causing the injury are paid out by judgment or settlement | (p)(3) | Settlement papers or the judgment |
| 5. Send proof of payment | Proof that the limits were paid is submitted to your UIM insurer | (p)(3) | The proof you sent and when |
| 6. Agree or arbitrate | Entitlement and amount are settled by agreement or by a single neutral arbitrator | (f) | Demand letters and the arbitration notice |
Do the at-fault driver’s limits have to be paid first?
Yes, as a general rule. Under (p)(3), UIM coverage “does not apply to any bodily injury until the limits of bodily injury liability policies applicable to all insured motor vehicles causing the injury have been exhausted by payment of judgments or settlements, and proof of the payment is submitted” to your UIM insurer.
Two points follow from that wording. First, if more than one insured vehicle caused the crash, the rule speaks of all of their policies. Second, payment alone does not finish the step; the proof has to reach your insurer.
Do you need your insurer’s consent before you settle?
Section 11580.2(c)(3) says the coverage does not apply to an injury when the insured, “without the written consent of the insurer,” settles with or prosecutes to judgment an action against a person who may be legally liable. Settling with the at-fault driver and signing a release without that consent can put the UIM claim at risk.
If you file suit against the owner or operator of the underinsured vehicle, (p)(6) requires you to give your UIM insurer a copy of the complaint “forthwith,” by personal service or certified mail, and to make pleadings and depositions available for copying at the insurer’s expense.
Practical rule: Under (c)(3), the consent has to be written. A dated copy of the request and of the insurer’s answer can show when consent was asked for and given.
How much can UIM pay?
Section 11580.2(p)(4) caps your UIM insurer’s maximum liability at your UIM limit, “less the amount paid to the insured by or for any person or organization that may be held legally liable for the injury.” Under (p)(5), the insurer that pays also gets reimbursement or credit for amounts you received from the underinsured driver or that driver’s insurer.
Formula: UIM maximum = U minus P, where U is your UIM limit and P is the total paid to you by or for anyone who may be legally liable.
That is a ceiling, not a promise. You still have to prove your damages, and the reductions below can lower the figure. UIM is not a payment of the gap between your damages and the other driver’s limits.
Illustrative hypothetical (not a case result)
Suppose the at-fault driver carries the minimum $30,000 per-person bodily injury limit, and that full $30,000 is paid to you in a settlement your insurer consented to in writing. Suppose your uninsured motorist limit and your UIM limit are both U (subdivision (n) has UIM offered at limits equal to uninsured motorist limits), and U is more than $30,000. The other car counts as underinsured under (p)(2), and your UIM insurer’s maximum is U minus $30,000, before any other reductions. If U were $30,000 or less, the other car would not be underinsured under (p)(2). These numbers show the formula only; real outcomes depend on the facts and the policy.
What else can reduce a UIM payment?
The statute lets a policy reduce what is payable in some situations:
- Medical payments coverage, (e): damages may be reduced by amounts paid or due under your automobile medical payment insurance.
- Workers’ compensation, (h)(1): a payable loss may be reduced by workers’ compensation amounts paid and the present value of amounts payable, excluding nonoccupational disability benefits.
- Others on the same policy, (h)(2): a payable loss may be reduced by what you are entitled to recover from another person insured under the same underlying liability policy.
- No stacking, (q): limits for two or more vehicles or two or more policies are never “added together, combined, or stacked.”
Medical liens can also affect what is left from any recovery. See our medical liens guide.
What happens if you and your insurer disagree?
Under section 11580.2(f), whether you are legally entitled to recover, and how much, is decided by agreement or, if you disagree, by arbitration conducted by a single neutral arbitrator. If you have or may have workers’ compensation benefits, the arbitrator does not proceed until your condition is stationary and ratable, and any demand for arbitration must include a declaration, under penalty of perjury, about whether there is a workers’ compensation claim.
What deadlines apply to a UIM claim?
Two sets of clocks can matter, and they come from different laws:
| Clock | What it covers | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Generally two years from the injury | A lawsuit against the at-fault driver | CCP section 335.1 |
| Two years from the accident | One of three steps under subdivision (i)(1), which is written in terms of uninsured motorist claims; whether it applies to an underinsured claim is a legal question (see below) | Ins. Code §11580.2(i)(1) |
| Five years from starting arbitration | Concluding an arbitration, with a later date possible when a workers’ compensation claim is involved | §11580.2(i)(2) |
| At least 30 days before a limitations period runs | While a claim under your coverage is pending, your insurer’s written notice of the limitation period, unless it has notice that a lawyer represents you | §11580.2(k) |
Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 generally gives two years to sue for injury caused by another’s wrongful act or neglect.
The statute’s two-year rule in subdivision (i) says no cause of action accrues under the coverage unless, within two years of the accident, a suit for bodily injury has been filed “against the uninsured motorist,” an agreement on the amount due has been concluded, or you have started arbitration by written notice to the insurer sent by certified mail, return receipt requested. Subdivision (i) is written in terms of an uninsured motorist. Subdivision (p), which governs underinsured claims and prevails over (i) if the two conflict, does not set its own timing rule, and (p)(3) makes exhaustion come first. The time to sue the at-fault driver under section 335.1 still runs, and the policy may have its own terms, so whether and how subdivision (i) applies to an underinsured claim is a legal question to check with a lawyer early. Subdivision (i)(3) also lets a court excuse noncompliance under estoppel, waiver, impossibility, impracticality, and futility, and (i)(4) lets the parties agree in writing to extend the time to conclude arbitration.
Exceptions and tolling rules can move these dates, and waiting for a report generally does not pause them. See our statute of limitations guide.
What are California’s minimum liability limits?
Under Vehicle Code section 16056(a)(2), policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2025 must carry at least $30,000 for bodily injury or death of one person, $60,000 for two or more people in one accident, and $15,000 for property damage. A driver who carries only these minimums can be underinsured under (p)(2) when your uninsured motorist limits are higher. For more on the minimums, see our financial responsibility law guide.
Where can you read more about uninsured motorist claims?
This page stays with UIM mechanics. Our uninsured motorist claims guide covers uninsured drivers:
How LA Law Group can help from Chatsworth
LA Law Group serves California personal injury clients from our Chatsworth office at 21540 Prairie St Unit A, Chatsworth, CA 91311. We can review your declarations page, whether the other vehicle meets the (p)(2) threshold, and the consent and timing steps before you sign a release.
No attorney fee unless we win your case. You are responsible for case costs regardless of the outcome.
Your initial consultation is free.
To learn more, visit our personal injury practice page or contact us. Call (866) 625-2529.
Video transcript
This video uses AI-generated visuals and an AI-generated voice. It is general information, not legal advice. Attorney Advertising.
An underinsured motorist claim is a claim on your own auto policy. Under Insurance Code section 11580.2, it can apply when the driver who hurt you had insurance, but with bodily injury limits lower than your uninsured motorist limits.
UIM coverage generally does not start until the at-fault driver’s liability limits have been paid through a settlement or judgment, and you send your insurer proof of that payment.
Before you settle with the at-fault driver or take that case to judgment, the statute ties coverage to your insurer’s written consent. If you sue the other driver, the statute says to give your insurer a copy of the complaint right away.
The most UIM can pay is your UIM limit minus what was paid by or for the people legally responsible. Limits from two or more cars or policies cannot be stacked. If you and your insurer disagree, the statute sends the dispute to a single neutral arbitrator.
Several deadlines can apply, including the general two-year time to sue the at-fault driver, so check them early.
LA Law Group serves California clients from our Chatsworth office. Learn more at bizlawpro.com.
This video uses AI-generated visuals and an AI-generated voice. It is general information, not legal advice. Attorney Advertising.
Sources checked
Official statutes and pages checked on October 30, 2026:
- Insurance Code section 11580.2, subdivisions (a), (c)(3), (e), (f), (h), (i), (k), (n), (p) and (q)
- Vehicle Code section 16056
- Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1
- California Department of Insurance, Automobile Insurance Information Guide, which confirms the minimum limits and the written waiver and does not address subdivision (i) timing for UIM
Statutes and agency pages can change. Re-check the official page before you rely on it.
Key takeaways
- UIM is a claim on your own policy when the other driver’s bodily injury limit is less than your uninsured motorist limit.
- The at-fault policies generally have to be paid out, and proof sent to your insurer, before UIM applies.
- Settling with the at-fault driver, or taking that driver to judgment, without your insurer’s written consent can affect UIM coverage under (c)(3).
- The most UIM can pay is your UIM limit minus what was paid by or for those legally liable.
- Medical payments, workers’ compensation, and same-policy recoveries can reduce it, and limits do not stack.
- Disputes go to a single neutral arbitrator, and how the timing rules apply to UIM is a legal question to check early.
Short checklist
- Find the uninsured motorist and UIM limits on your declarations page.
- Get the at-fault driver’s bodily injury limit in writing.
- Ask your insurer for written consent before signing any release.
- Send a copy of any complaint to your UIM insurer right away.
- Send proof that the at-fault limits were paid.
- Note the two-year time to sue under CCP section 335.1, and check the UIM timing with a lawyer early.
This article is for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Reading it does not make LA Law Group your lawyers. Results depend on the facts and California law. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.
Photo: Taylor Hunt on Pexels (photo 20654900), Pexels License. Cropped and resized to 1600x900; no other edits.
Frequently asked
What is an underinsured motorist claim in California?
It is a claim under your own auto policy when the at-fault driver had insurance, but with bodily injury limits lower than the uninsured motorist limits on your vehicle. Insurance Code section 11580.2(p)(2) calls that an underinsured motor vehicle.
When can I make a UIM claim?
Generally only after the bodily injury liability limits of every insured vehicle that caused the injury have been paid out through settlements or judgments, and proof of that payment has been sent to your UIM insurer. That is the exhaustion rule in Insurance Code section 11580.2(p)(3).
How much can UIM pay?
At most, your UIM limit minus the amount paid to you by or for the people or organizations that may be legally liable, under Insurance Code section 11580.2(p)(4). Your damages still have to be proven, and the policy may allow other reductions, such as for medical payments coverage or workers' compensation benefits.
Do I need my insurer's permission before settling with the at-fault driver?
Insurance Code section 11580.2(c)(3) says the coverage does not apply if you settle with, or prosecute to judgment, a claim against a person who may be legally liable without your insurer's written consent. Policies and releases vary, so a lawyer can review them before anything is signed.
What if my insurance company and I disagree about the UIM claim?
Under Insurance Code section 11580.2(f), whether you are legally entitled to recover, and how much, is decided by agreement or, if you disagree, by arbitration before a single neutral arbitrator.
Is there a deadline for a UIM claim?
More than one clock can matter. Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 generally gives two years to sue the at-fault driver for injury, and under Insurance Code section 11580.2(p)(3) UIM coverage does not apply until that driver's limits are paid by settlement or judgment. Subdivision (i) of section 11580.2 has a two-year rule written in terms of uninsured motorist claims. Whether and how it applies to an underinsured claim is a legal question, and the policy may also have its own terms, so check with a lawyer early. Exceptions and tolling rules can move these dates, and waiting for a report generally does not pause them.
Can I combine UIM limits from more than one car or policy?
No. Insurance Code section 11580.2(q) says limits for two or more vehicles or two or more policies are not added together, combined, or stacked to set the coverage available.
Is UIM coverage optional in California?
Only through a written agreement. Section 11580.2(a) generally requires uninsured motorist coverage in auto bodily injury liability policies, (n) treats uninsured and underinsured coverage as a single coverage, and (p)(7) includes underinsured coverage in those policies. The insurer and a named insured may delete it, or reduce it to an amount not less than the Vehicle Code section 16056 minimums, only by a written agreement in the form the statute sets out.
Attorney Advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.