← Insights

Comparative Negligence in California: How Shared Fault Affects Your Claim

By Aryan Amid
Close view of two vehicles touching in a minor collision on a road near railroad tracks, with no people and no readable text.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and is not to be construed as legal advice. No attorney-client relationship exists based on the review of this article, and none of the information in this article is legal advice.

Short answer: California follows pure comparative negligence. In Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804, the California Supreme Court held that liability is assessed in proportion to fault “in spite of the fact that the plaintiff is equally at fault as or more at fault than the defendant.” Your own share of fault reduces your damages by that percentage but does not by itself bar recovery. The defendant has to prove your share (CACI No. 405). For multiple defendants, Civil Code section 1431.2 limits each defendant’s share of noneconomic damages to its own percentage of fault.

From Contributory Negligence to Comparative Fault

Civil Code section 1714(a) makes everyone responsible for injuries caused by a lack of ordinary care, “except so far as the latter has, willfully or by want of ordinary care, brought the injury upon himself or herself.”

Before 1975, that exception was read as the contributory negligence rule, which the court in Li described as one that “bars all recovery when the plaintiff’s negligent conduct has contributed as a legal cause in any degree to the harm.” Li replaced it with “a system of comparative negligence, which assesses liability in direct proportion to fault,” and chose the “pure” form of that system.

How Pure Comparative Negligence Works

Under the pure form, the injured person’s negligence is not a bar to recovery. As a later Court of Appeal decision quoted in the CACI Sources and Authority put it, a claimant’s own negligence is considered “not as a bar to his recovery, but merely as a factor to be considered in measuring the amount thereof.”

The Judicial Council’s civil jury instructions (CACI) show how this plays out at trial:

  • CACI No. 405, Comparative Fault of Plaintiff. The defendant must prove that the injured person was negligent and that this negligence was a substantial factor in causing the harm. If the defendant proves both, the injured person’s damages are reduced by the jury’s percentage of the injured person’s responsibility, and the judge calculates the actual reduction.
  • CACI No. 406, Apportionment of Responsibility. When the negligence or fault of more than one person was a substantial factor, the jury assigns a percentage of responsibility to each person on the verdict form. The percentages must total 100 percent. The jury makes a separate finding of the total damages and does not consider anyone’s percentage when it does so.

As a simple hypothetical, if a jury assigned an injured driver 25 percent of the responsibility, the damages the jury found would be reduced by 25 percent. The same math applies at any percentage, which is what makes the rule “pure.”

Comparative fault is not limited to car crashes. The CACI Sources and Authority describe it as a “flexible, commonsense concept” that lets a jury weigh each party’s responsibility whether it rests on negligence, strict liability, or other theories, and CACI No. 1207A applies the plaintiff’s comparative fault in strict product liability cases.

Pure Comparative Negligence vs. Other Rules

The main alternatives are:

  • Contributory negligence, the old all-or-nothing rule that Li rejected, under which any negligence by the injured person barred recovery.
  • Modified comparative negligence, which reduces damages by the injured person’s share of fault but bars recovery once that share reaches a set level. Li considered this kind of system and declined to adopt it.

Other states choose their own rules, so the result can change if a case is governed by another state’s law.

For an example of how another state changed its approach, see this overview of Florida’s tort reform.

Multiple Defendants and Proposition 51

When more than one defendant is responsible, California separates two kinds of damages. Civil Code section 1431.2, added by Proposition 51, provides:

  • Noneconomic damages (such as pain, suffering, inconvenience, and emotional distress): each defendant’s liability is several only, not joint, and is limited to that defendant’s percentage of fault.
  • Economic damages (objectively verifiable losses such as medical expenses, lost earnings, and repair costs): section 1431.2 does not change the rule for these. Under American Motorcycle Assn. v. Superior Court (1978) 20 Cal.3d 578, cited in CACI No. 406, a concurrent tortfeasor can generally be liable for the full amount of those damages, reduced only by the injured person’s own share of fault.

The California Supreme Court held in B.B. v. County of Los Angeles (2020) 10 Cal.5th 1, also cited in CACI No. 406, that section 1431.2 does not let an intentional tortfeasor reduce its liability for noneconomic damages based on the negligence of others. For more on these categories, see our guide to economic damages.

Other Rules That Can Limit Recovery

Comparative fault is one rule among several. For example, Civil Code section 3333.4 generally bars an uninsured vehicle owner, or a driver who cannot show financial responsibility, from recovering noneconomic damages for their own injuries, no matter how fault is divided. Our guide to California auto insurance minimums explains the insurance requirement.

Deadlines also matter. Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1 generally sets a two-year deadline to sue for personal injury, and claims against a public entity usually require a government claim first. See our statute of limitations guide for details.

Comparative Fault in Insurance Claims

Most claims are handled through insurance before any jury is involved. An insurer may take a position on how fault should be divided, but that position is not a court finding. If the case goes to trial, a jury decides the percentages under the instructions above.

Evidence such as the police report, photos, witness information, and medical records can help show what happened. Our guides on getting a police report, parking lot accident fault, pedestrian accident fault, and filing a personal injury claim cover these steps.

We also have a separate Spanish-language guide on this topic: negligencia comparativa en California.


If you were hurt and fault is disputed, LA Law Group, APLC can review what happened and explain your options. You can reach us at https://www.bizlawpro.com.

Photo: Nikita Nikitin on Pexels (photo 10102312), under the Pexels License. Cropped to 16:9, resized to 1600x900, and a vehicle emblem was obscured. It is an illustration, not a photo of a firm case.

Frequently asked

Does California use comparative negligence?

Yes. In Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975) 13 Cal.3d 804, the California Supreme Court replaced the all-or-nothing contributory negligence rule with comparative negligence and held that it applies in its pure form.

What is pure comparative negligence?

Under the pure form, the court in Li explained, liability is assessed in proportion to fault even when the injured person is equally at fault or more at fault than the defendant. An injured person's share of fault reduces the damages but does not by itself bar recovery.

Can I recover if I was mostly at fault in California?

Under the pure comparative fault rule adopted in Li, being more at fault than the other party does not by itself bar recovery. Your damages are reduced by your percentage of responsibility. Other rules, such as Civil Code section 3333.4 for uninsured drivers, can still limit what you recover.

Who has to prove that the injured person was at fault?

The defendant. Under CACI No. 405, the defendant must prove that the injured person was negligent and that this negligence was a substantial factor in causing the harm. If the defendant proves both, the damages are reduced by the injured person's percentage of responsibility.

How does a jury assign fault percentages?

Under CACI No. 406, when more than one person's negligence or fault was a substantial factor in causing the harm, the jury assigns a percentage of responsibility to each person on the verdict form, and the percentages must total 100 percent. The jury finds the total damages separately, without considering the percentages.

What is Proposition 51?

Proposition 51 added Civil Code section 1431.2. In an action for personal injury, property damage, or wrongful death based on comparative fault, each defendant's liability for noneconomic damages, such as pain and suffering, is several only and is limited to that defendant's percentage of fault.

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.